First impressions count: How does format influence consumer perceptions of protein drinks?
Despite the saying, most of us do judge books by their covers. Restaurants by their menus. And products by their packaging. In fact, research suggests that we spend as little as nine seconds deciding whether to buy an individual food item.
UK Food Standards Agency, ‘Consumer Responses to Food Labelling: A Rapid Evidence Review’, 2022
In that brief window, format, appearance and familiarity can all shape our expectations.
But how much do these first impressions influence what we think a product can actually do? It’s an important consideration in protein drink formulation – and our new research reveals how format itself can shape expectations before nutritional benefits even enter the picture.
To find out what drives consumer choice in protein beverages, we worked with Bolt Insight to interview more than 200 consumers in the UK, Germany and France who had purchased a protein drink within the last three months. We compared their thoughts on RTD protein drinks and protein yoghurt drinks. We asked them about everything from protein sources, preferred drinking occasions, and benefits – and what they said revealed three key takeaways about the role of format in protein drink formulation.
Protein RTDs vs yoghurts: what consumers told us
Finding 1: Occasion matters
In consumers’ eyes, there is no single moment for choosing a high-protein drink. Instead, they choose the best option for what they need in the moment. This means deciding whether to buy a RTD protein drink or shake or yoghurt based on the time of day, whether they’re hungry or thirsty, or whether they want a treat.
But these choices aren’t just about the occasion itself. They’re influenced by the associations and sensory expectations that come with a product’s format. Drinking yoghurts, for example, are more often tied to morning and breakfast occasions, while RTD drink and milkshake formats appear more in afternoon and evening as a way to boost energy during a long day, or provide a post-workout treat.
Takeaways:
- Consumers choose based on hunger, thirst or wanting a treat – not format preference
- The top reason for rejecting a format is occasion mismatch
- Yoghurts are seen as a way to stay fuller for longer, making them a practical breakfast
- RTD drinks and shakes are more commonly consumed later in the day
Finding 2: Consumers expect different things from different formats
Preconceptions of format heavily shape the benefits consumers associate with a product. In our research, consumers frequently described RTDs like protein shakes as more indulgent – reflecting the role of a milkshake as a sweet treat. On the flip side, they saw drinking yoghurts as closely linked to benefits like digestion and healthy snacking – perhaps drawing on yoghurt’s existing health halo.
But there’s common ground, too. As dairy-based drinks, both formats have strong associations with protein’s role in muscle-building and overall health, meaning these benefits resonate regardless of format.
Takeaways:
- 37% said RTD dairy beverages milkshakes are indulgent
- 57% said yoghurt drinks are better for digestion
BUT
- 52% said both drinking yoghurt and RTD dairy beverages help build muscle
- 45% said both are good for overall health
Finding 3: Across formats, protein quantity matters most
Across all three markets, grams of protein per serving is the top-scoring willingness-to-pay claim. Shoppers expect around 20 g per serving in France and the UK and 25 g in Germany. But simply naming the protein source, adds little value on its own. Consumers need to understand what that protein will do for them. While protein quantity ranked highest overall, benefit-led claims linked to tangible outcomes, such as muscle recovery and appetite management, were the second- and third-highest ranked claims, consistently increasing willingness to pay across markets.
So, what does this mean for protein drink formulation?
For formulators, the message is clear: a product’s format does more than determine how it is consumed; it shapes what consumers expect from it. Effective protein drink formulation means bringing those first impressions together with the right nutritional proposition: choosing a format that fits the occasion, building on the benefits consumers already associate with it, and making the protein content and its purpose clear. In other words, get the format right, and the nutritional proposition has a better chance of landing.
Meet Nutri Whey™ ProHeat: Your secret weapon for protein drink formulations
Our microparticulated whey protein helps you meet consumer expectations for high-protein drinking yoghurts and RTDs, combining the nutritional benefits of whey with the taste and texture consumers expect from their favourite drinks:
- Exceptional taste and texture to create smooth, enjoyable drinking yoghurts and RTDs without compromising on protein content.
- Low viscosity for a lighter consistency that flows easily and makes high protein drinking yoghurts and RTDs more refreshing and easy to drink
- Heat stability to overcome traditional whey formulation challenges, such as gelling during processing, helping you develop high-protein drinks with a consistent texture.
FrieslandCampina Ingredients: Your ultimate protein partner
Combining consumer insight, deep protein expertise and application know-how, we help beverage brands turn consumer needs into high-protein concepts that deliver on taste, texture and nutritional benefits. With science-backed solutions – like Nutri Whey™ ProHeat – we can help you find the right format, occasion and claims to turn protein opportunities into products that win on shelf.
Get in touch to start your next high-protein innovation.
Ask-the-expert: exploring the latest protein science for healthy ageing nutrition
Read moreFirst look: the 2026 nutrition trends you need to know
Read moreSubscribe to our newsletter
For more than a century we’ve been creating quality ingredients delivered with passion. Whether we’re inspiring ideas from drinks to bars, or supporting how to manufacture products in better ways, our customers can count on us to deliver, time and time again.
Subscribe
